Your Take: Visionary Collaborations

Brady Vercher | February 16th, 2008 Email Share

Dolly Parton and Porter Wagoner

Collaboration between established artists has created some interesting and successful pairings throughout country music’s lifetime. Porter Wagoner and Dolly Parton, Loretta Lynn and Conway Twitty, Emmylou Harris and Gram Parsons, Alan Jackson and George Strait, and with the advent of technology, Alison Krauss & Keith Whitley, and Hank Williams and Bocephus. Last year, Raising Sand, the project by Alison Krauss & Robert Plant, had the accolades rolling in, as did the Last of the Breed album and tour from Merle Haggard, Willie Nelson, and Ray Price.

Johnny Cash, Waylon Jennings, Kris Kristofferson, and Willie Nelson came together for Highwayman, but imagine if Merle Haggard had been included. Would a collaboration between Ashton Shepherd and Jamey Johnson produce a clash of twang, or supremely awesome songs? Dale Watson and Gary Allan both are independent, bucking trends, and releasing good music and although their musical styles aren’t the same, they’ve both suffered tremendous losses that they could draw upon for inspiration. The probability for something special is there. Josh Turner and Don Williams are a duo whose styles would mesh well and I would definitely be interested in seeing what they could come up with.

If you the opportunity to choose any artists that you wanted to collaborate on a project, who would you choose and why?

  1. Jordan Stacey
    February 16, 2008 at 10:34 am Permalink

    I heard that before they got dropped Jessi Alexander and Jon Randall were working on a duet album, I think that that could be a very interesting project. I also agree with the Ashton & Jamey idea, that would be awsome.

  2. Baron Lane
    February 16, 2008 at 10:51 am Permalink

    Nick Cave and Hank III
    Neko Case and Dale Watson
    Tool and Steve Earle
    Te Drive By Truckers and the Replacements

  3. Paul W Dennis
    February 16, 2008 at 10:54 am Permalink

    The Porter and Dolly collaboration was NOT one of established stars. The first of their duets, “The Last Thing On My Mind”, debuted on 12/12/67. By that time Porter had already charted 27 singles with three records that went to #1 on Billboard and/or Cashbox. Plus he had a syndicated TV show that had been running for several years

    At that stage Dolly had had only two charting singles, the biggest of which, “Dumb Blonde” had only gotten to #17 on Billboard. It would be late 1970 before she had her first top ten record

    A similar example would be the Ernest Tubb-Loretta Lynn pairings of the mid-1960s. Their voices didn’t blend especially well but the duets work because of the force of the personalities involved. ET was a far bigger star than Porter Wagoner (he was elected to the CMHOF within months of the the second duet released) and Loretta Lynn , while somewhat more successful than Dolly at the time of the pairing (she had had five charting records with three top tens) was still a fledgling star

    John Prine & Mac Wiseman - now THAT is a pairing of superstars.

    I’d like to hear a pairing of Dale Watson & Lee Ann Womack for an album’s worth of songs.

  4. Rick
    February 16, 2008 at 11:00 am Permalink

    In an interview Blake Shelton said the one new female country singer he’d most like to do a duet with was Ashley Monroe, who is also one of Miranda Lambert’s best friends. Because both Blake and Ashley have strong traditional country sensibilities, I think their duets would potentially be a wonderful thing.

    Jamey Johnson recorded a fine duet with Catherine Britt on a traditional heartbreaker titled “With This Ring (I Thee Unwed)” which was sadly never released. I would have gladly paid for an entire album of duets from those two. Matching Jamey up with Ashton Shepherd would be a stroke of genius, sort of a Conway and Loretta for the new century. And how about Sarah Buxton with, well anyone as long as it got her back on the radio…..

  5. Kelly
    February 16, 2008 at 11:26 am Permalink

    I like Baron’s choices, but herre are some of mine…

    phil stacey & carrie underwood
    bobby brown & carnie wilson
    jamie foxx & one of the other rascal flatts guys

  6. Brady Vercher
    February 16, 2008 at 12:17 pm Permalink

    Paul, I didn’t suggest that all the artists were stars and my bad for insinuating that Dolly was established. I like the Dale Watson and Lee Ann Womack pairing quite a bit.

    Rick, doesn’t Blake like the 80’s country with all the weird stuff going on? No matter, I think a Blake/Ashely duet would be cool. Now I gotta go find the Jamey Johnson/Catherine Britt duet, it sounds like it oughta be good.

    Kelly, I was enjoying the comments ’till I read yours. You’re bannneedddd…

  7. Matt C.
    February 16, 2008 at 12:25 pm Permalink

    George Jones said in a radio interview on WSM that his favorite contemporary duet partner is Patty Loveless. If the stellar “You Don’t Seem to Miss Me” is any indication, an entire album would be great, adn Jones said that this project is on his wish list.

  8. Mike W.
    February 16, 2008 at 12:34 pm Permalink

    Gary Allan and Shelby Lynne

  9. Rick
    February 16, 2008 at 12:36 pm Permalink

    Brady, I got into country music big time back in the mid 80’s when the “new traditionalist” movement was coming on board sperheaded by Randy Travis and Alan Jackson, God bless them… This movement thankfully replaced the “Urban Cowboy” soundtrack artists dominance of the early 80’s. I don’t really know of any weird stuff during that period that you refer to (except for maybe K.T Oslin?). I consider the subsequent hijacking of country radio by Garth Brooks and Shania Twain the beginning of the “weird stuff”…

    More duet pairings I’d love to hear:
    Jeff Bates and Elizabeth Cook
    Sunny Sweeney and Wayne Hancock
    Joe Nichols and Amy Dalley

    Gosh, this topic is a hay wagon full of fun!

  10. Brady Vercher
    February 16, 2008 at 12:48 pm Permalink

    Matt, that pairing sounds like it could go somewhere. Is George Jones voice still up for it?

    Mike, I didn’t care for Shelby Lynn’s latest album at all, but they could be interesting together.

    Rick, here’s the article I was remembering about the 80’s stuff. It’s the third question where he’s talking about synthesizers. I haven’t really gotten into Jeff Bates, but the duet between Elizabeth Cook and Bobby Bare, Jr. last year was great. I missed a Sunny Sweeney & Corb Lund show last month and I’m kickin’ myself over it, but pairing her up with Wayne Hancock would be pretty sweet.

    Keep all the great ideas comin’, except for you, Kelly.

  11. pchcowboy
    February 16, 2008 at 1:31 pm Permalink

    Dale Watson and Hank Williams III. That would make for the hardest duet album ever.

  12. Josh Preister
    February 16, 2008 at 1:36 pm Permalink

    First I have to say that I was beyond excited for the release of the Reba Duets CD because honestly who doesn’t love a good duet? And was so disappointed with the song selections. It had such promise and it felt like they hurriedly put it together and didn’t even try and aim for some decent music & lyrics.

    Second, I love the idea of Ashley Monroe & Blake Shelton. Basically because I love Ashley Monroe. Does anyone know if she is ever going to release her album? I feel like it will never see the light of day… So sad.

    Now to my dream duet which I have narrowed down to:
    Dierks Bentley and Miranda Lambert
    Keith Urban and Martina McBride

    I would also love for Faith & Tim to do another duet with a more serious undertone like that of “Angry All the Time” and “Like We Never Loved At All”

  13. Brady Vercher
    February 16, 2008 at 1:56 pm Permalink

    Josh, I don’t particularly care for the idea of duet albums with multiple artists, they just seem like a compilation album put together for the sake of the names on the songs rather than creating compelling music.

    Jim broke the news earlier this year that Ashley Monroe was dropped, so who knows what will happen to her album. I believe it’s still available on Rhapsody if you want to try getting a copy of it.

  14. Kelly
    February 16, 2008 at 2:29 pm Permalink

    ok, being serious now. i have really enjoyed the jesse dayton/brennen leigh duet album. while they arent a nationally recognized pairing, jesse is quite the star in many parts of the southwest and you could say that his featuring leigh is his version (i stress his as a smaller version) of Porter introducing the newcomer Dolly to a certain crowd .

    How about:

    -Dale Watson w/Sunny Sweeney
    -James Hand w/Wayne Hancock

  15. Kelly
    February 16, 2008 at 2:41 pm Permalink

    I also enjoyed Marty Stuarts recent duets album. Even with some great left-of-canter choices such as teaming with OCMS for “I can see for miles and miles”, it was the more traditional numbers that rang true for me, like his and Loretta’s version of “Will you visit me on sunday”.

    How ’bout this (give me some rope on this):

    A younger, twangier version of “Does He Love You”? I wasnt a huge fan of the original with Reba/Linda Davis, I felt it a bit too soapy (thanks to the video i suppose). I think a Miranda/Ashton duo could give it an edge that could cut away the fatty broadway style-melodrama that plagued the original. by going heavy on the guitar and bitterness, these two could make a similar tale one that all-ages could relate too, i imagine.

  16. Matt C.
    February 16, 2008 at 3:15 pm Permalink

    Brady, I don’t know if his voice is up to it. It’s still passable on his recent Merle Haggard duets album, though that was a good two years ago and George’s decline might be more glaring against Patty Loveless’ voice. I will say that George’s strength has never been his technical ability, so that even in concert - I’ve seen him twice in the past year - he doesn’t sound half bad most of the time. It’s probably one of those things where they’d just have to cut a few tracks and see what happens, though the sooner the better as far as George’s voice is concerned.

  17. bobby
    February 16, 2008 at 3:24 pm Permalink

    dierks bentley and miranda lambert is a great suggestion
    also,
    miranda lambert and keith urban
    Joe Nichols and Jamie O’Neal(I always thought they had similar voices)
    Wynonna and Keith Urban
    Reba and George Strair
    Vine Gill and Trisha Yearwood
    Gary Allan and Ashley Monroe

  18. Peggy
    February 16, 2008 at 4:21 pm Permalink

    Yes, regarding the Gram & Emmylou pairing, now that she is in the CMHOF, maybe Gram stands a chance??
    sign up here!

    http://www.gramparsonspetition.com

  19. CF
    February 17, 2008 at 4:46 am Permalink

    I would love a George Strait & Lee Ann Womack duet album. I like their duet, “Good News, Bad News”, but still felt it could have been better (I know they have much more in them!).

    I’d also love a Vince Gill & Patty Loveless duets album. I think their voices are perfect for one another.

    This is kinda random, and I just thought about it: Alison Krauss & Mark Chesnutt?

  20. Leeann
    February 17, 2008 at 8:41 am Permalink

    I’d like that Garth and Trisha album to be recorded, though I’ll need something more inspiring than “In Another’s Eyes.”

    A Vince and Alison bluegrass album would be cool.

    A George Jones and Patty Loveless album would be great. George’s voice has always sounded old, even when he was young. For awhile, I thought that his voice got better as he aged, because the old quality was being more perfected. Now, however, I started noticing that it’s not working in his favor as much these days, even as far back as his “The Blues Man” duet with Dolly Parton.

    A Merle Haggard and Clint Black project would be fun too.

    And I really like the idea of Dierks and Miranda!

  21. ccf
    February 17, 2008 at 10:23 am Permalink

    Kelly,

    Those duet cd you would like to see would be Awesome ! Wayne the Train and James Hand or Dale and Sunny wow the thought makes the hair on my arm stand up.

  22. Reg Matthews
    February 17, 2008 at 9:48 pm Permalink

    Dale Watson and Merle Haggard should be as good as the great Buck Owens and Dwight Yoakum duets.

  23. Kelly
    February 18, 2008 at 8:41 am Permalink

    Thanks CCF, with Hand and Hancock, you have two grizzled, nasaly traditionalists just lettin’ people know how it is and how it hurts….

  24. Lanibug65
    February 18, 2008 at 8:45 am Permalink

    One of my favorite duets is Lee Ann Womack and George Strait — and I also like Ashley Monroe with Dwight (better than with Ronnie Dunn)

  25. ccf
    February 18, 2008 at 10:37 am Permalink

    Kelly,

    No I can’t imagine two better traditionalists than those two they have the right twang to their voices.

    Have you ever heard of The Bays Brothers? I hear a heavy Hank Sr and Wayne the Train influence. I really like “Staring in Vain”

    http://cdbaby.com/cd/baysbrothers2

    or

    http://www.baysbrothers.com

  26. Kelly
    February 18, 2008 at 10:47 am Permalink

    Thanks, CCF, I’ll check ‘em out. What I love about them, and especially Hand, is that there is true life experience and pain to augment the twang that truly relates feeling and not just a sound.

    How cool would it be to year “Yesterday’s Wine” done by those two???

  27. ccf
    February 18, 2008 at 10:50 am Permalink

    I forgot to mention

    Billy Don Burns he is a true outlaw in every sense of the word

    http://www.billydonburns.com

    or

    http://www.myspace.com/billydonburns

    I also like Roger Wallace

    http://www.myspace.com/rogerwallace

  28. ccf
    February 18, 2008 at 10:54 am Permalink

    Wow yesterday’s wine it give me chills thinking about it. The other artist Billy Don he has a song called Dark side of the spoon he also wrote it It really nails what it would be like addicted to Heroin with a line like

    “He rides through the night on a lost highway through a hole he made in his vein to a plastic place where desperate die on a dirty street called shame. “

  29. Kelly
    February 18, 2008 at 11:41 am Permalink

    Hey Brady?!?! You wanna call me out when i am jokin’ around about dream collabs, but now that i have been having serious duet talk you leave me hangin’?? Whats up with that??? Dont make me get on the phil stacey msg board and let them know that you are bashing him again!!!!

  30. Brady Vercher
    February 18, 2008 at 6:28 pm Permalink

    Sorry for ignoring you, Kelly, we don’t all have cushy jobs that allow us to slack off ;) Dale Watson & Sunny Sweeney could probably come up with something good between them. The James Hand/Wayne Hancock would probably only appeal to hardcore fans. I like both guys alright, but it’d have to be exceptional music to get me excited. As for Miranda & Ashton, it might be kinda cool for the Texas/Alabama deep south/good local music thing going on, but a Miranda & Ashley Monroe duet would be just as interesting. Good suggestions.

    Matt, I’m hoping to catch George Jones for the first time next month at the rodeo here in Austin, so I guess I’ll find out whether or not his voice is up to snuff.

    It’s interesting that everyone here would prefer to see traditional pairings and we haven’t seen any multi-artist suggestions ala The Highwaymen.

  31. Matt B.
    February 19, 2008 at 4:42 am Permalink

    This is a cool idea and I’m always up for a good duet (and I don’t mean songs that ‘feature’ artists as duets, something Mr. Brooks has done for years).
    Someone mentioned Mark Chesnutt and Alison Krauss. That’d be brilliant and was hinted at with the hit song “It’s Not Over” which featured Vince Gill and Alison Krauss.

    Speaking of Garth Brooks, I would be interested to hear him and Trisha Yearwood finally release an actual Duet record.

    I also think Mark Chesnutt and LeeAnn Womack would be interesting.

    Sarah Buxton would actually probably work really well with Marcel as a duet partner. They both have that rhaspy quality to their voices.

  32. Kelly
    February 19, 2008 at 8:27 am Permalink

    Thanks Brady, sometimes a brutha just needs a little positive reinforcement and hey, I love having a job where i can slack off and feel bad for those of you that dont, but there does seem to be a lot of commenting going on during the day ;)….

  33. Leeann
    February 19, 2008 at 9:56 pm Permalink

    Oooh! Marcel and Sarah Buxton. That would be interesting.

  34. Lucas
    February 20, 2008 at 1:38 pm Permalink

    ARTISTS I’D LIKE TO DO A DUET WITH:
    Garth Brooks - The guy is just my hero, plain and simple. He knew the difference between being traditional and being boring. He was able to combine neotraditional country with fun. My MySpace songs are my leftovers, I’m saving my best songs because I was advised to by a friend. But I’d still look like a second grader standing next to Garth.

    Taylor Swift - Based on age similarity and style. This would be a fun song for me personally, I’m a huge Taylor fan.

    ARTIST I’D LIKE TO SEE DO DUETS TOGETHER:
    Keith Whitley (if he was still here) & Tracy Lawrence - Their voices would be amazing together. Maybe two guys going for one girl, a song about a friend passing (one singing as the passed friend and the other as the best friend), or who cares… just a duet would be amazing!

    Tracy Byrd & Clint Black - A song by these two guys would be a good time on a disc! Imagine at a concert. Guest appearance by Neal McCoy maybe?

    Dierks Bentley & Carrie Underwood - They could have one of those cool/mysterious broken-up boyfriend/girlfriend love songs. The video would probably be pretty nifty too!

    Josh Turner & Randy Travis - Come on, this one is obvious. It would be HUGE at radio.

    Brooks & Dunn & Alan Jackson - I’d pay a million dollars to hear a really great duet. That is, if I had a million dollars.

    I HAVE to see Dolly and Kenny sing Islands In The Stream live, that’s a goal.

  35. Brady Vercher
    February 20, 2008 at 1:48 pm Permalink

    Kelly, I get to slack off sometimes, but if I do it too often, I don’t get to eat, and that seems to be the one thing I have in common with Gary LeVox.

    Good suggestions, Lucas. Here’s a video of Randy Travis and Josh Turner performing “King of the Road.”

  36. Lucas
    February 20, 2008 at 4:13 pm Permalink

    I love that video, I’ve wathed that Crossroads SO many times. I think they should record something as a single!

  37. Big D
    February 29, 2008 at 8:50 am Permalink

    A list of dream teams for me:
    Don Williams and Alison Krauss
    Ronnie Dunn and Merle Haggard
    George Strait and Garth Brooks (the Super Bowl of collaborations)

  38. Brody Vercher
    February 29, 2008 at 9:02 am Permalink

    Your Strait/Brooks collaboration reminded me of an article I linked to the other day.

    “My God,” an admiring young Garth Brooks once told Farrell while watching [George Strait] offstage during a 1989 or 1990 show. “I have seen men who were self-contained, but he goes too far.”

  39. Jeremy Potts
    March 16, 2008 at 7:51 pm Permalink

    Keith Urban and John Mayer.

  40. Mike Parker
    April 10, 2008 at 2:00 pm Permalink

    Roger Miller and Todd Snider

  41. James
    April 22, 2008 at 8:51 am Permalink

    Don Williams with Lee Ann Womack

    Kid Rock and Susan Tedeschi (Yes I am aware they are neither “country” but both have dabbled enough and I think would kick some country ass together.)

    Jo Dee Messina and Chris Young

  42. Mark
    May 24, 2008 at 12:41 pm Permalink

    Carrie underwood, Taylor Swift and Kellie Pickler should all do a song together. It would me amazing if they all went out on concert together.

  43. Larry
    May 30, 2008 at 8:27 am Permalink

    Loretta Lynn recently mentioned that she would like to do a duet with Elton John. Now that would surely made a great record!! I hope that wish is actualized!

Leave a Comment


Sponsor

Tagged In This Article

// // // // // // // // // // // // // // // // // // // // // // // // //

Current Discussion

  • leeann: I agree that his career did not decline. I feel that the quality of his songs h...
  • hairandtoenails: I disagree Joey. Toby's commerical success has declined. Between 2001 and 2004 v...
  • Stormy: You could listen to rap and hear basically thi same song. Personally, I prefer ...
  • joey: his career hasnt declined hes still putting out great songs all the time. not al...
  • Jim Malec: Julie, I have to say, that's the snarkiest comment an article of mine has ever...
  • Stormy: Dustin: I think we all understand Just A Dream. Its like a murkily written Dre...
  • Trey: ok first of all quit saying he wasted time by "stopping to record this song" yea...
  • Rosy: Hey Justin, you just remember back home in that little town that you grew up in,...
  • bresenolouie: In this haunting tale of the young widow, she is confused about the sudden tragi...
  • Julie: I'm only an occasional reader of this site, and I'm beginning to see why. This ...

Recently Reviewed Albums

  • Randy Travis - Around The Bend
  • Ray Scott - Crazy Like Me
  • Reckless Kelly - Bulletproof
  • Mark Chesnutt - Rollin’ With The Flow
  • Becky Schlegel - For All The World To See
  • Jewel - Perfectly Clear
  • Eleven Hundred Springs - Country Jam
  • Julianne Hough