Your Take: Making A List, Checking It Twice…

Karlie Justus | November 28th, 2009 Email Share

This week in the Wall Street Journal, journalist Barry Mazor looked at the role family plays in Roseanne Cash and Ricky Scaggs’s new releases.

Mazor talked with Skaggs, who released Solo: Songs My Dad Loved earlier this fall, and Cash, whose album The List came out in October, about what these projects meant to each of them:

… And both Ms. Cash and Mr. Skaggs have released new collections this fall in which they interpret afresh the old, deeply established American songs their fathers, now deceased, had loved and recommended to them. Ricky Skaggs’s “Solo: Songs My Dad Loved” (on his own Skaggs Family Records) is built on instrumentals, gospel songs and country ballads that Hobert Skaggs, a welder by trade and a practiced amateur musician, began teaching his son from earliest childhood. Rosanne Cash’s “The List” (Manhattan Records) culls numbers from a list of 100 essential songs that her father—the now legendary, and in her childhood often absent, Johnny Cash—gave her at age 18. She had just finished high school, was more steeped in the Beatles than country, and was contemplating a possible career of her own.

“At that same time my dad gave me the list,” explained Ms. Cash in a recent interview in Nashville, “I was receptive to it, but I don’t think I really understood the import of it until now. . . . The list was what he was, what informed him. And he had as deep and broad an understanding of the evolution of Southern and American music as anyone alive. He had thousands of songs in his mind, and he could sing them all; he had gone so deeply into the lexicon that this list encompassed Appalachian, protest songs, history songs, gospel, delta blues, early country—all of it. It’s as if he were a martial-arts expert and he passed down a secret. So it’s not a salute to him; it’s about the secret—which is our legacy of music. …

In addition, Mazor notes that both Cash’s daughter Chelsea Crowell and Skaggs’s daughter Molly are following in their musical footsteps, continuing the chain.

To borrow from a question we featured in September’s Skaggs giveaway, what are the songs that a family member shared with you that inspired your love for music?

Also, if you had to come up with a list of essential country songs for a loved one, what would they be? Johnny gave Roseanne 100 of them, but tell us your top 10.

  1. Ken Morton, Jr.
    November 28, 2009 at 9:57 am Permalink

    Coat Of Many Colors- Dolly Parton
    Folsom Prison Blues- Johnny Cash
    El Paso- Marty Robbins
    Lost Highway- Hank Williams
    Crazy- Patsy Cline
    Always On My Mind- Willie Nelson
    The Dance- Garth Brooks
    The Devil Went Down To Georgia- Charlie Daniels
    She Stopped Lovin’ Her Today- George Jones
    Seven Spanish Angels- Ray Charles & Willie Nelson

  2. highwayman3
    November 28, 2009 at 10:40 am Permalink

    My mom, when I was 3 or 4, I was young, had a mix tape she played in the car, and to this day 2 songs from that tape stand out and were my first exposure to country and everytime I hear them takes me back to driving around when I was a kid, Dolly Parton’s -Why’d You Come In Here Lookin Like That’ and Alan Jacksons ‘Chasin That Neon Rainbow’ So I guess she inadvertantly exposed and inspired me to love country music.

  3. Stormy
    November 28, 2009 at 10:50 am Permalink

    One year my dad gave me a walkman and the follow two cassettes:
    Anne Murray Sings the Songs of the Sesame Street Generation
    Jimmy Martin–Greatest Hits.

    That was weird.

  4. Mike Wimmer
    November 28, 2009 at 10:52 am Permalink

    As a teen, I loved metal and hard rock. I didnt like Country, hated it. My dad played the radio in the barn all the time and it was tuned to this classic country station he loved. One day they played Hurt by Johnny Cash. Since that day I have been hooked, so I would say the songs they played on there by Cash, Willie and Waylon pretty much got me into Country.

  5. Noeller
    November 28, 2009 at 11:09 am Permalink

    My parents cassette copy of Nitty Gritty Dirt Band’s “Partners Brothers and Friends” album was highly influential for me. For years, as a young adult, I tried to find another copy of it but it was out of print. Thank goodness for ITunes, and I was able to download it earlier this year. A flood of memories hit me like a tidal wave – what a wonderful feeling.

    The other one that sticks out is the CCR – Chronicle greatest hits album that my folks used to listen to ad nauseum, and instilled my love of southern rock/country.

  6. Andrew
    November 28, 2009 at 11:42 am Permalink

    He Stopped Lovin’ Her Today – George Jones
    I Walk The Line – Johnny Cash
    Your Cheatin’ Heart – Hank Williams
    There Stands The Glass – Webb Pierce
    Amarillo by Morning – George Strait
    The Dance – Garth Brooks
    Angel Flying Too Close to the Ground – Willie Nelson
    Act Naturally – Buck Owens
    Mama Tried – Merle Haggard
    Make The World Go Away – Eddy Arnold

  7. Catherine S.
    November 28, 2009 at 5:35 pm Permalink

    This is definitly the must gift year for country music fans! I was very happy to see the women in country make such a fine stand at the AMA’s. In case you have forgotten here are some of the best females in the country music genre, sure to spark some great gift ideas for the music lover in your home.

  8. Steve Harvey
    November 29, 2009 at 5:47 am Permalink

    1. 25 Minutes To Go – Johnny Cash
    2. Cold, Cold Heart – Hank Williams Sr.
    3. Crazy – Willie Nelson
    4. The Thunder Rolls – Garth Brooks
    5. The King of Broken Hearts – Jim Lauderdale
    6. Smoke Rings In The Dark – Gary Allan
    7. Do I Ever Cross Your Mind – Dolly Parton and Chet Atkins
    8. Love Hurts – Emmylou Harris and Gram Parsons
    9. Sunday Morning Coming Down – Kris Kristofferson
    10. Jolene – Dolly Parton

  9. Adam
    November 29, 2009 at 1:15 pm Permalink

    My mom used to play the Urban Cowboy Soundtrack, Earl Thomas Conley, and Jo-el Sonnier a lot when I was young. Her boyfriend of many years was into Hank Jr. and Dwight Yoakam. I guess you could say all of these artists contributed to my love for country music.

  10. Rick
    November 29, 2009 at 7:51 pm Permalink

    Okay, I’m bored with this repeat topic so I’m going to do something completely different!

    I want to list the rock and country artists whom I think are grossly over-rated in many ways, from album sales to perceived significance. Okay, here we go:

    Grossly Over-Rated “Country” Artists:
    1.) Garth Brooks (I hope he “Stays In Vegas…”)
    2.) Shania Twain (Mutt’s musical mannequin)
    3.) Carrie Underwood (Pop Idol Divabot Prototype)
    4.) Taylor Swift (‘Teeny screecher w/ adolescent fixation)

    Grossly Over-Rated Rock Artists:
    1.) Bruce Springsteen (Dylan can’t sing either, but at least his songs really meant something)
    2.) U2 (About as pleasant as sitting on a Joshua Tree)
    3.) Stevie Nicks (Not even Lindsey Buckingham could redeem her)
    4.) Prince (Strangeness confused for greatness)

    There, isn’t this a lot more fun? And what a great way to create controversy! (lol)

  11. Mojo Bone
    November 30, 2009 at 12:21 pm Permalink

    In no particular order:

    Rocky Top -Osborne Bros
    You Ain’t Woman Enough -Loretta Lynne
    Don’t Come Home A Drinkin’ -Loretta Lynne
    Uncle Penn -Bill Monroe
    I Walk The Line -Johnny Cash
    Knoxville Girl -Delmore Bros
    Cold, Cold Heart -Hank Williams
    (It Wasn’t God Who Made) Honky-Tonk Angels -Kitty Wells
    Walkin’ The Floor Over You -Ernest Tubb
    Rollin’ In My Sweet Baby’s Arms -Buck Owens

  12. Jon
    November 30, 2009 at 3:22 pm Permalink

    Nice to see Bill Monroe mentioned, but FYI, it’s “Uncle Pen” – short for Pendleton.

  13. silvio
    December 1, 2009 at 1:08 pm Permalink

    Love for music – my mom had some great records, lots of Beatles and Elvis. Love for country – my dad played Waylon a lot. Birthday and Christmas gifts for him were easy as I would always get him a Waylon he didn’t have.

    As for my Top 10 (man, it’s hard to limit to just 10, but here goes)…
    Blue Yodel No. 1 (T For Texas) – Jimmie Rodgers
    I’m So Lonesome I Could Cry – Hank Williams
    Big River – Johnny Cash
    A Good Year For The Roses – George Jones
    El Paso – Marty Robbins
    What’s Made Milwaukee Famous (Has Made A Loser Out Of Me) – Jerry Lee Lewis
    For The Good Times – Ray Price
    Luckenbach, Texas – Waylon Jennings
    Angel Flying Too Close To The Ground – Willie Nelson
    Hot Burrito #1 – The Flying Burrito Brothers

Leave a Comment


Sponsor

New American Voices Video

Tagged In This Article

// //

Current Discussion

  • Jim Malec: @Jon: I don't know what happened, but we're totally on the same page lately.
  • Jon: 4 different versions of a song - must be some kind of record.
  • Kelly: @Brady - of course, you are right about how many types of songs were recorded over and over way back ...
  • Ashley: jason i love your music the song keep the girl and the truth are my favorite yet keep it ...
  • luckyoldsun: Paul, You beat me to the punch on that one. Frankie Laine had the definitive versions of "Jezebel," "Ghost Riders In the ...
  • Steve from Boston: I think Occasional Hope's on the right track about the concept for Patty's new video. And I like it a ...
  • Scott: WOW,the comments I've read sure are "deep." Really everyone, it's just a song. Enjoy it, take whatever you ...
  • stormy: Josh: But you have to remember that, in the aftermath of the earthquake, a so-called Christian man DID say it was ...
  • SMB: How could you not point out Josh's blatant theft of Keith Urban's "Love Pain & the whole crazy thing" album ...
  • Steve: I'm surprised this wasn't mentioned. CMT has a new Studio 330 Sessions showcasing Kellie Pickler's outstanding vocals and songs. http://www.cmt.com/videos/studio-330-sessions/kellie-pickler/475944/makin-me-fall-in-love-again.jhtml?id=1630380

Recently Reviewed Albums

  • haywire-icon
  • bill-icon
  • rwh-icon
  • needyouicon
  • ch-icon
  • Sugarland - Gold and Green
  • mark-icon
  • clark-icon