Suzy Bogguss – “In Heaven”
I have nothing against songs built around hooks. Indeed, most of my favorite songs feature strong and memorable hook lines. However, when writing a song that’s so dependent on a revelatory hook as this one, you have to make sure the hook is good. Unfortunately, this one’s not.
The concept of a widow telling her deceased husband that she’s found a new love is a good one that should make for a great country song. Here, despite the ethereal instrumentation, the writers choose to structure the first verse as though Bogguss is simply talking to some ex to whom she is painfully close, until revealing that “I’m in heaven here on earth and you’re in heaven.”
Such a weak, heavy-handed hook line is a major disappointment after the buildup of the first verse and the rest of the song isn’t much better. Bogguss’ vocal is fine, but the production and the writing are too sappy for my taste.
![]()
Listen: Suzy Bogguss – “In Heaven”
If you enjoyed this article, be sure to subscribe to our feed or receive updates via email.
Popular Stuff
Sponsor
Tagged In This Article
Current Discussion
- Stormy: Tiffany--had you actually read my response you would see that I agreed with you that Jake is likely a very ...
- Stormy: I don't want to sound to old, but back in my day Lee Greenwood could take a morning ride that ...
- Rose: Hey, Jamey saves souls, too: the soul of country music. (For my money, I like to picture Jesus as ...
- linda: i have listened to country music for years. i remember johnny duncan from the 70's. he was one of our ...
- Nicolas: The Canadian one came a couple days late, so the American one might also
- Erin C: As today being the day it is, we all have the right to Freedom of Speech but that doesnt include ...
- Lucas: It's the 4th.... where's the America songs article? I expected you guys to write it up at 3AM while ...
- Lucas: I like Jake Owen's voice, but I don't like this song. It feels like something that lacked thought on ...
- Tiffany: This is addressed to Stormy. I am not a teenage fanbot. I am 25 and most of Jake's ...
- Rick: Okay, it may not be country but my favorite song about Canada is "Take Off" by Bob and Doug McKenzie ...
As much as we love girl singers, we love songs about girl singers even more. Here's just a few of the many tribute songs out there.
Step away from the river and up to a jukebox, because heartbreak is only temporary, but a good song about drowning yourself—like a diamond—lasts forever.
Who sings like dead flowers? Find out the answer to that question and many more in June's mailbag.
What do you think about music labels "testing the waters" with a single before providing access to an artist's entire album?
What country artist, young or old, would you recommend as a must-listen artist to a newcomer on his/her journey through country music, and what would your essential song picks be?
Miranda Lambert - "Dead Flowers" "Dead Flowers" marks the maturation of a phenomenally talented but still budding songwriter into a full-fledged artistic powerhouse.
Taylor Hicks - "Seven Mile Breakdown" Hicks has soul, but this record doesn't. It's a disappointing entry from one of American Idol's least disappointing attempt-a-crossover artists.
For episode four, we feature a couple of acts who have been helped along the way by winning talent competitions. Darryl Lee Rush was the inaugural victor of the Shiner Rising Star Contest and Caitlin & Will were victorious on last summer's Can You Duet from CMT. 







14 Comments
RSS for comments on this post | Trackback URI for this post
August 6, 2007 at 2:42 pm Permalink
Matt, I’m gonna have to agree with you on this. The lyrics are weak and drawn out, the music itself reminds of something from the late 80’s to early 90’s, and the chorus is just way too cheesy for me to appreciate what Suzy is trying to accomplish with this song. I think Suzy is a wonderful talent, but you wouldn’t know it by listening to this song.
August 13, 2007 at 10:28 am Permalink
When Suzy Bogguss performed the song “Heaven” at the Grand Ole Opry some time back, she could see a number of people in the audience reaching for their handkerchiefs and she herself had to look away to keep her composure as she sang. I have loved this song very much since the first time I heard it, and I often find myself humming it. It would make me very happy if others could hear it as well. Maybe the people in that audience had been through that experience themselves or knew somebody who had. Of course their having had that experience themselves would make them more able to understand what the song is about.
August 13, 2007 at 10:50 am Permalink
Joe,
I agree with you. I personally loved the song and gave it a shining review on my site. But my father died earlier this year so it might be that I’m more open emotionally to things like this right now. Heck, I wept during the end of the last Harry Potter movie, and also reading the last book.
August 21, 2007 at 10:32 am Permalink
I think its a beautiful song. You dont hear songs like this too often so its a nice change. She has an amazing voice and the lyrics of this song Im sure we all can relate to one way or another. My grandfather reccently passed and it makes me think of him. The first time I heard this song I stopped what I was doing to listen to it, and I dont do that very often. I will admitt it brought tears to my eyes.
August 25, 2007 at 4:27 pm Permalink
This song is awesome. Anyone who has lost someone or knows someone who has lost someone understands. The person gone wanted the other to go on and find happiness again and even though it takes time; it happens in some cases. To find love twice in life is great and she wanted to share her happiness. I think it is great that she/he can go on in life.
September 17, 2007 at 10:44 pm Permalink
I think the song is great because I lost my husband two and a half years ago and my dad two months and one day before that. I just started seeing someone a little over 4 months ago and my mother just started seeing someone a couple of months ago. My daughter was driving from one work site to another when she heard this song and she said she just started crying because it sounded so much like my situation with her dad and my new love. As soon as she got home from work she called “mom you have got to call the radio station and request this song In Heaven by Suzy Bogguss. It will make you cry, it sure did me.” I requested it and yes I cried and so did my mom even though she’s not in love, yet. I have requested it again for my new love and he said this is how you explained to me you felt a couple of months ago you just didn’t have the music with it. Our radio station says this is a really much requested song here, so it must be good. I think Suzy does it great and it makes you feel like you have God’s blessings, too. It is great to find love twice in a life time.
October 5, 2007 at 8:16 am Permalink
I’m just two weeks from the first anniversary of my wife’s death, and wondering what to do with the rest of my life, so the song has a lot of meaning to me. The “hook” is subtle, but how many fish are caught with brazen hooks?
February 9, 2008 at 5:44 pm Permalink
I’ve been a professional musician and artist for 35 years and always wondered “who” has the authority to judge art or music. It’s polite to criticize only if you don’t know what you’re talking about.
February 10, 2008 at 2:40 pm Permalink
The song is about the child they had together. The song implies a father killed two or three years ago in Iraq by President Bush and now the mother of their child (who the father never met) has regained control of her life, overcome her grief, and is moving on. It is a beautiful, amazing, and moving song. I have two toddlers and this song brings tears to my eyes. I am so thankful (although I definitely do not believe in a god) that we live in a free country and that I am able to hold my beautiful children in my arms without fear of missiles and suicide bombs worn by feeble unfortunates and detonated by cold-hearted killers. Peace to you all.
February 10, 2008 at 3:55 pm Permalink
Matt C.
I ran across your review while I was researching this song. Your analysis might be a bit too technical. I suppose you could listen to Sara Beth by Rascal Flatts and not get wet eyes, too. The odds are against it, but I hope for your sake, if that’s what you wish, you never have to go through any experiences that will allow you to be affected by this song. Most grown ups, however, understand that those experiences are what makes life wonderful, and country music is an expression of that life. This song reminded me of that.
I heard this song yesterday for the first time when Suzy performed it live on A Prairie Home Companion, and the audience didn’t seem to have any complaints. She also said her husband wrote the song. I hope he was trying to tell her anything, but it may have saved my life.
I’ve been divorced for many years and will never marry again, but a couple of years ago I met a wonderful woman. Her husband died long ago under questionable circumstances and left her to raise their two kids alone, which she’s done amazingly well. Although I know she’s fallen in love with me, I just don’t seem to be able to return it; too much baggage, I guess. I shouldn’t have gotten married in the first place.
I’ve have had some hard times recently and was selfishly contemplating something similar when I heard Suzy sing this song. Once I heard it, I couldn’t believe I was being so selfish I was thinking about doing the same thing to this wonderful woman for a second time. I hadn’t been able to find a way to tell her. So, I got a recording of the song, learned the lyrics and chords in a few hours, and I’m going to sing it to her when she visits later this week. I’ve already committed it to memory and know it by heart, I just haven’t gotten the feeling into it yet. That shouldn’t be a problem, because even though I’ve played it dozens of times already, I still can’t get through it without crying. Ultimately, though, it caused me to stop feeling sorry for myself and get back in the fight. I’ve got a lot to live for and I’ve got a few asses to kick, yet.
This is the sin of the commercialization of art. This song might not mean anything to you, but an artist never knows when they’ll produce that one piece of work that means everything to someone, if only them. That’s what keeps the good ones going, not your silly reviews. I hope I someday get to thank Suzy for this song. And her husband.
I do have you to thank for being able to listen to the song over and over until I could get it down. Thanks at least for that.
Jim C.
March 2, 2008 at 1:28 am Permalink
The whole point of the song is the emotion, and if you have lost a dear loved one, it is right on target. You can call it sappy, or overly emotional if you want, but if you allow yourself to hear it from the perspective of those thousands of people it touches directly, maybe you will hear the genuine worth and beauty of it.
March 9, 2008 at 12:04 am Permalink
I lost my wife 2 1/2 years ago to cancer. Lying on her deathbed, she made me promise two things: to raise our daughter well and to find myself a new love.
I am in love with and engaged to a widow who lost her husband just over 3 years ago.
This song captures beautifully the emotions that both my fiancee and I confront–the passage from grief to life again; the laying aside of the last remnants of guilt that you might be somehow betraying the memory of your first love, now lost to you forever; the regathering of your life and the reawakening to a new beginning; the closing of a chapter and the opening of a new one. It’s all here, and with a tenderness that is both appropriate and emotional.
If music is supposed to adhere to some esoteric formula with hooks that you can rate and standards that are consistent and routine, then by all means apply the review above. If, however, music is designed to touch the soul and elicit an emotional response and if lyrics are there to give voice to essential human experience, then the review above is wrong. Sorry, but from one who knows these emotions firsthand and believes that music is meant to reveal to us our own humanity, this song gets a lusty THUMBS UP!
March 9, 2008 at 3:45 am Permalink
Steve,
Your story is a country song in the making, and I suggest you copyright it immediately. Seriously. What a touching story … it rings true to me, though my loss was not through passing to another, better world, but from divorce. And yes, I still mourn the loss, and just wish I could “get past” this point of denying it’s over, blaming myself, and move on to a new love. Additionally, your critique/review is spot on. Also, something that is missing from the other reviews, is McGraw’s reference to Kristofferson’s style, and I’m sure I misquote, “it might not even rhyme”. Anyway, God bless you and your new love, I hope I may be so blessed as you as to find that new love which does not replace the old one, but adds to the wonder of life and love as we mortals know it.
Chris
July 17, 2008 at 2:13 pm Permalink
I disagree with this review. If you download the iTunes version of this album, it comes with some extra interview pieces where Suzy talks about a few of the tracks and what they mean. This song was written by Suzy’s husband, and it is about a friend of theirs who’s wife had recently passed away. You don’t hear many songs these days (in mainstream music anyway) that derive from and express such an emotional situation. This song is real, and it feels and sounds real, and to me that is what music is all about.
Leave a Comment