Collin Raye - “Quitters”

Matt C | September 27th, 2007 Email Share

collinraye1.jpgApparently Collin Raye has decided that the best way to resurrect his radio career is to start singing like Gary LeVox. If there’s any justice in the world, he’s wrong.

Admittedly, Collin Raye has never been a great vocalist, and his whiny, sappy vocal style is clearly a progenitor of the Rascal Flatts scourge. However, this recording is a new low in the career of an artist who fell just a few hits short of superstardom in the nineties. It’s a painfully cheesy song about a wheelchar-bound child who’s “going to leave the giving up for the quitters.” Forgetting the cliche-ridden and re-tread lyrics, the vocal performance is absolutely grating. Throw in a few too many amped-up power chords and its easy to lump this in with the very worst music that’s coming out of Nashville.

Thumbs Down

  1. Jim Malec
    September 27, 2007 at 11:46 pm Permalink

    I disagree about Raye’s vocal chops as a rule, but I agree emphatically with your review of this song and his performance on it.

  2. Matt
    September 29, 2007 at 6:38 am Permalink

    Collin Raye’s vocals are actually pretty strong but since he’s the one who got me into country 100%, I am probably biased. But I agree it’s not a great song. Still I hope he gets airplay so he can make some more music.

  3. Matt C.
    September 29, 2007 at 8:00 am Permalink

    Collin Raye doesn’t have to get radio airplay to continue making music. Given that his last two singles have been terrible, it would probably be best if he stopped chasing radio revival.

  4. Kevin
    September 29, 2007 at 2:18 pm Permalink

    I don’t like this song, but Collin Raye remains one of my favorite male singers from the 90’s. I think he’s a fantastic vocalist.

  5. Shelly
    October 4, 2007 at 2:00 pm Permalink

    I heard this song for the first time today. I really liked it. I had tears in my eyes before the end of it.

  6. Chris N.
    October 4, 2007 at 4:02 pm Permalink

    How many songs have there been in the last few years about wheelchair-bound people learning to walk again? Off the top of my head there’s Joe Nichols’ “The Impossible” and Bucky Covington’s “I’ll Walk.”

  7. Jen the Country Chickadee
    October 13, 2007 at 8:28 pm Permalink

    Song (co-written by Canadian rising star George Canyon) is thought-provoking and inspiring. Collin Raye has always had a great voice ever since he started getting radio play in the early 90s. If y’all ever get the chance to see him in concert, you’ll know that his powerhouse vocals cannot be matched, well except for maybe Martina McBride. PS — I love all country. Alan Jackson and Vince Gill were the ones who got me listening. But Collin’s music spanned the gamut between pop on some, honky tonk on others, subjects from love to hurt to stronger subjects and never any of the fluff that some new country stars are singing about.

  8. Kendra
    October 23, 2007 at 11:33 am Permalink

    Collin Raye has been and is my favorite country artist. He does not sing what everyone else is singing and his songs always have meaning behind them, meanings that anyone can relate to. This song hasn’t grown on me yet, but I’m sure it will. There are sooo many other country artists out there who look in to a career in something other than country music. Collin Raye however, is not one of them. He is right where he belongs.

  9. Amanda
    November 6, 2007 at 3:44 pm Permalink

    I completely disagree. Collin Raye is a great singer. I love this song and am going to buy the CD immediately. All of his songs are great-and he was around LONG before Rascal Flatts!

  10. mother of Rose
    January 14, 2008 at 8:11 am Permalink

    Your comment about it being cheesy……. is uncalled for maybe you meant it to be about the singer but it doese sound like you are talking about the boy coming out of the wheelchair. I have seen more physically disadvantaged people( especially children ) be more inclined not to give up. They have a determination and are not quitters. I myself have a child that is 3 and in a chair and had many other problems. She was not to live over a year old but has defyed all the odds and has a dtermination you would not believe unless you see it.

  11. Jonathan Tanner
    January 28, 2008 at 8:04 pm Permalink

    What you call “cheesy” is actually a true story. I know the young man the song was written about. He is actually the main character in the video too. Despite his challenges, he keeps plugging away with such a genuinely positive approach, that he is constantly sought out to mentor others in his same situation. Hopefully if one of your family members experiences something like this, they would have his same wonderful spirit that a musician would choose to sing about.

  12. hairandtoenails
    January 28, 2008 at 10:55 pm Permalink

    Its great that people are determined to succeed even in the face of adversity, and there is nothing cheesy about that. But that doesn’t mean that a song that discusses such people isn’t cheesy.

  13. Carrie Murch
    February 4, 2008 at 8:29 am Permalink

    What a heartless review. There are many people who take inspiration from this song. And I’m sure it hits especially close to home for Collin Raye who has a Granddaughter who is disabled.
    He wasn’t writing it to “resurrect” his career, he was writing it to give “hope” to the people who need it most.

  14. Andrea Cook
    February 22, 2008 at 4:39 pm Permalink

    I loved this song and video! I don’t even like country music much! Unfortunately, I too was paralyzed recently and it is overwhelmingly depressing. On a day where I was discouraged, this video/song lifted my spirits!

  15. Lucsa
    February 22, 2008 at 4:56 pm Permalink

    I wish there was a station out there sort of like a Lost Highway Records for the radio. Take the artists that aren’t necessarily getting all the glory anymore but are still making great music.

  16. Trudy
    March 12, 2008 at 11:16 pm Permalink

    I don’t know who this Matt C guy is, but he sure doesn’t know what he’s talking about when it comes to rating a singer/song! I’ve been a fan of Collin Raye for a long time, and I’ve never heard a song by Collin that I didn’t like. I believe he is a far better singer than Gary LeVox could ever be. He voice is just as good as Vince Gill, Alan Jackson or George Strait, and he should get as much air time as the rest of them. And so what if there are a couple other songs out there about people in wheel chairs…how many songs have been written about Trucks, Beer, Breakups, Ect… without people complaining about the topics?
    I think “Quitters” is a good song, and I hope Collin keeps putting out many more songs in the future.

  17. hairandtoenails
    March 13, 2008 at 12:24 am Permalink

    Trudy writes, “how many songs have been written about Trucks, Beer, Breakups, Ect (sic)…without people complaining about the topics.”

    I think the difference between “trucks, beer, etc” and wheelchair-bound kids who “won’t give up” is that the former songs generally don’t go for an easy pull at the heartstrings, while the kid-in-a-wheelchair songs tend to. When I listen to the typical kid-in-a wheelchair song, I often feel like the writer is trying to cheaply manipulate me; when I hear yet another song about trucks, I just feel like I’m hearing a Ford ad.

    The kid-in-wheelchair songs seem to be simplistic. Rarely does the kid show any resentment at his situation, any anger at God, any sense of helplessness, even if temporary, or what not. They are psychologically unrealistic: they take a complex human experience (losing a capability one once had) and turn it into a simplistic teerjerker.

    Of course, though, some singers do reference things like “trucks, beer” et cetera, as a shortcut to invoking certain values. Luke Bryan’s “Country Man” and Shannon Brown’s “Corn Fed” invoke these sorts of images to celebrate country life, but in the end their celebrations wind up being superficial.

    And thats what makes these “trucks, beer, etc” songs (and the kid-in-wheelchair songs) so bad. Something wonderful, complex, and imperfect such as country life or the strength of the human spirit even in the face of adversity becomes cheapened into stock images designed to make the listener cry-on-cue rather than offer lyrics that offer a window into the complexity and wondrousness of the human experience.

    Sorry this is so long winded!

  18. Leeann
    March 13, 2008 at 8:12 am Permalink

    Many times, Collin’s songs have fallen short of my taste, but I’ve always been intrigued by his voice. I think he hits his high, powerful notes in an interesting way. It’s like you don’t think he’ll be able to hit the note, but he does end up hitting it in the end.

    As for this song and other songs that focus on disabilities, I have to take them on a song to song basis. I won’t say that all songs that focus on people with adversities are cheesy, but the songwriter has to be extremely careful not to be patronizing and the singer has to be a great interpreter of a song that could otherwise seem heavy handed. I think that the song crosses into the danger zone of heavy handedness if the disability is glamourized, which is often the case in such songs. There’s nothing glamourous about a disability and songs shouldn’t make those without one feel otherwise. Just like anything else, people with disabilities should not be generalized. I mean, people without disabilities aren’t positive every minute. They don’t always make the best of their situations. So, why assume that people with disabilities are always positive and always make the best of their situations? I’m definitely not suggesting that they always feel depressed or sorry for themselves, but I am saying that just about every song that I hear on this subject is very singular, which is not realistic. So, in the end, it seems kind of patronizing to sing about such a singular aspect of the protagonists of these songs. I think that’s why we cringe when another song is sung about someone with a disability who overcomes all of the odds. I think we know that there’s more to the story.

  19. hairandtoenails
    March 13, 2008 at 1:05 pm Permalink

    Leeann - I agree.

    Here’s a song about a disabled person that I really like, “Ruby Don’t Take Your Love To Town.”

    In “Ruby” the disabled person is a real person with real feelings, his situation is humanized, he isn’t a mere symbol designed to teach us “never give up.”

  20. Leeann
    March 13, 2008 at 1:24 pm Permalink

    Ditto, Hairandtoenails!

  21. Sherry
    April 18, 2008 at 10:24 pm Permalink

    Wow! I love Collin Raye! I think his voice is absolutely amazing. My sister and I never miss a concert when he’s in our area. Collin’s songs always have a story worth hearing. He’s amazing. We actually saw him perform in our po-dunk outdoor theater here in Orem, Utah a few years ago. To make a concert even remotely worth the price of a ticket is hard to do. Collin Raye’s performance that evening was one of the best I’ve ever heard. I brought a friend who’d never heard of him, and she’s an avid fan now!

  22. Drew
    July 27, 2008 at 5:46 pm Permalink

    Call me sappy or cheesy or whatever, but I really liked this emotional cover by Raye, and acutally do like his voice for the most part. If you aren’t a fan of Raye in particular, then I’d recommend listening to George Canyon’s original version of the song, a singer-songwriter from Eastern Canada.

Leave a Comment


Sponsor

Tagged In This Article

//

Current Discussion

  • Matt B.: Oh and Leeann, my first Vince Gill album was "When Love Finds You" followed by "I Still Believe In You." ...
  • Razor X: "Matt B. summed up the reaction of some of the folks here with this line in his review: “there’ll be ...
  • Matt B.: Leeann, I think you just emphasized why I wrote what I did in my review (I was probably thinking of Rick ...
  • tommy: i think this whole 'controversy' thing has taught me that people belly-ache too much. big deal, she doesnt like the ...
  • Leeann Ward: North Texas, you just proved Brady's point. Carrie Underwood's uber fans didn't like the song choice, yet they'll still ...
  • northtexas: "There’ll be those out there that will love this song and defend it to death for the simple fact that ...
  • scooter: Well if Carrie does shift more towards the traditional, she has to start somewhere. I think a better indicator of ...
  • nm: I thought I heard quite a bit of wanting to sound like Waylon on Dierks's second album. I haven't ever ...
  • Matt B.: Brady, you're right about North Texas' quote of my review. I said that because I knew there'd be people ...
  • CMW: Dudley: You acknowledge that "the choice of 'I Told You So' has potential strategic implications for Carrie’s positioning in country music" ...

Recently Reviewed Albums

  • Charlie Louvin - Murder Ballads and Disaster Songs
  • Brandon Kinney - Smells Like Texas
  • Trace Adkins - X
  • Blake Shelton - Startin' Fires
  • Johnny Cash - At Folsom Prison Legacy Edition
  • Rodney Hayden - 12 Ounce World
  • Brad Paisley - Play
  • Randy Houser - Anything Goes