CMT, The New, Watered Down MTV

Brody Vercher | November 17th, 2006 Email Share

“How CMT is making cowboy boots, pickup trucks, and woeful ballads cool. But not too cool.”

That’s the premise for an article that Fast Company ran in its magazine last week. It sounds interesting, but then you think about what CMT has become recently and it’s just a watered down MTV, bad taste and all. They haven’t really done anything original with the channel but rip off what has already been done by their older brother. Country Fried Videos is Jackass, Trick My Truck is Pimp My Ride, and what does the Miss America Pageant have to do with country music? In their obsession to garner high ratings they’ve cut back on the country music videos and stocked up on the crap that every other channel already airs. Dukes of Hazzard re-runs are the only good thing that have come from MTV-lite. That show rocks.

These two city guys, Hitchcock and Engleman, who are heading the re-branding effort, don’t seem to understand what country music is. They’re trying to make it mainstream by alienating the people who really love country music and playing stuff that appeals to the masses, like pop music. All for a few extra bucks. It’s a little condescending if you ask me, but you can decide for yourself.

Besides, cowboy boots, pickup trucks, and “woeful ballads” were cool long before these two guys got a hold of them.

Leave a Comment


Sponsor

Tagged In This Article

Current Discussion

  • CMW: Dudley: You acknowledge that "the choice of 'I Told You So' has potential strategic implications for Carrie’s positioning in country music" ...
  • Matt B.: I actually think this song was written quite well, regardless of what we interpret his intentions to be. And, ...
  • Brady Vercher: I haven't seen anything bordering on outright hate for the song, but the converse of that statement also holds true ...
  • northtexas: Matt B. summed up the reaction of some of the folks here with this line in his review: "there’ll be ...
  • dudley: Stormy: My point is that Wilcox is accusing the Carrie camp of trying to claim the traditionalist mantle with the ...
  • Gloria: I loved Carrie's performance and I loved the song! Rascal Flatts, well, that do nothing for me! I couldn't stand ...
  • Stormy: Dudley: The marketing of a song isn't the reality of that song. Nashville: Actually, it explains a lot about ...
  • plain_jo: I really like Tomlinson's voice and I think the song is just a reflection of what we as Americans feel ...
  • Leeann Ward: Great review! Songs like these are frustrating. I didn't like "One Wing In The Fire" either though. His voice ...
  • Brady Vercher: Tomlinson is certainly taking a look back at a non-existent utopia. Did he forget about the Great Depression, WWII, the ...

Recently Reviewed Albums

  • Charlie Louvin - Murder Ballads and Disaster Songs
  • Brandon Kinney - Smells Like Texas
  • Trace Adkins - X
  • Blake Shelton - Startin' Fires
  • Johnny Cash - At Folsom Prison Legacy Edition
  • Rodney Hayden - 12 Ounce World
  • Brad Paisley - Play
  • Randy Houser - Anything Goes