Carter’s Chord - “Young Love”

Jim Malec | December 20th, 2007 Email Share

One of the best parts about having a job which requires reading through an endless series of agonizingly long artist bios is that every once in a while you’re bound to unearth a choice nugget that hilariously “exaggerates” an artist’s qualities. And let me tell you, I’ve come across my share of exaggerations. But this one takes the cake: “The sound of Carter’s Chord is as country as a verdant hillside and as fresh and invigorating as a sip of well water.”

Oh my. As country as a verdant hillside? As fresh and invigorating as a sip of well water? Not really. Not quite. Not even close. What are they pushing here, anyway, Herbal shampoo?

There is nothing at all fresh about the debut single from upcoming Show Dog trio Carter’s Chord. The sisters’ Robertson (Becky, Emily, and Joanna) have a sound that lacks the panache and musical balls of the Dixie Chicks and the lyrical cleverness of SHeDAISY. And that makes it a sound that is generally…well, lacking.

So a more accurate line for the group’s bio might read something like: “The sound of Carter’s Chord is as bland as a boiled potato.” CC’s vocal performance on “Young Love” is entirely nondescript; a pale and meek delivery that relies on borderline-sufficient harmonies to add texture to what is an otherwise boring track.

And the song? Oh my. We’ve been here before. Sneaking out. Driving down back roads. Making out in the woods. Breaking up because “autumn” is pulling us apart. Oh the pain. Oh the tragedy.

Oh no.

Thumbs Down

Listen: Carter’s Chord - “Young Love”

  1. Pierce
    December 20, 2007 at 4:53 pm Permalink

    I saw these ladies at he CMA Fest, and thought that they were pretty good live. I don’t remember hearing this song, but one called “Different Breed” was pretty good.

    I agree with you here… pretty bland.

  2. Peter Kohan
    December 20, 2007 at 8:09 pm Permalink

    While artists (and their labels) select what songs they want to sing and release - isn’t “lyrical cleverness” solely the domain of the songwriter(s)?

  3. Jim Malec
    December 20, 2007 at 9:26 pm Permalink

    Yes, Peter, but all of the above mentioned artists are also billed as songwriters.

  4. Peter Kohan
    December 20, 2007 at 10:38 pm Permalink

    Jim - I hate to call you out on this one, but, from the Carter’s Chord web site…

    Young Love
    Written by: Hillary Lindsey, Aimee Mayo, Scooter Carusoe

  5. Peter Kohan
    December 20, 2007 at 10:41 pm Permalink

    … the group does have other songs they have written - they might be good or bad or somewhere in between, but THIS SONG ain’t theirs.

  6. Matt C.
    December 20, 2007 at 10:52 pm Permalink

    Uh oh, are we going to hear from Aimee Mayo again?

    Peter, I’m not sure what your point is. Because the artist didn’t write the single, Jim can’t criticize the lyric? As you pointed out, artists and labels choose songs to record. It’s certainly fair to criticize them for choosing a bad song.

  7. Jim Malec
    December 20, 2007 at 10:55 pm Permalink

    No, you’re right, and I don’t mind you “calling me out” on it. I knew that the trio didn’t write this.

    Ultimately, an artist is defined by the songs that they record whether or not they wrote those songs. And, like it or not, female trios will be compared to other female trios.

  8. Peter Kohan
    December 21, 2007 at 1:49 pm Permalink

    Jim - That’s a good explanation. If you were writing an album review I think your criticisms would be more valid than in reviewing this particular single. Once their album is out you could reasonably talk about the songs the group itself is responsible for writing and compare them to the more established, similar female groups.

    Matt - My point is that if you’re going to criticize the lyric, then you discuss the writers, not that artist, if they have had no hand in writing the cut. You can criticize the artist or label for making, in the critic’s judgement, a poor song choice, but not for the song itself.

  9. Double-L
    February 20, 2008 at 12:24 am Permalink

    I saw Carter’s Chord live in Nashville at last year’s CRS and was impressed. They were one of my three takeaway faves. I hope their next single fares better.

Leave a Comment


Sponsor

Tagged In This Article

// //

Current Discussion

  • Leeann Ward: I've seen Carrie fans still be pretty enthusiastic about this song outside of the private message boards; they put on ...
  • northtexas: "I love the song. I just hate the way Carrie sings it." Fair enough! I have no problem with ...
  • northtexas: "North Texas, you just proved Brady’s point. Carrie Underwood’s uber fans didn’t like the song choice, yet they’ll still support ...
  • Leeann Ward: The Key and These Days are my favorites of Vince's. I liked When Love Finds You back when it ...
  • Matt B.: Oh and Leeann, my first Vince Gill album was "When Love Finds You" followed by "I Still Believe In You." ...
  • Razor X: "Matt B. summed up the reaction of some of the folks here with this line in his review: “there’ll be ...
  • Matt B.: Leeann, I think you just emphasized why I wrote what I did in my review (I was probably thinking of Rick ...
  • tommy: i think this whole 'controversy' thing has taught me that people belly-ache too much. big deal, she doesnt like the ...
  • Leeann Ward: North Texas, you just proved Brady's point. Carrie Underwood's uber fans didn't like the song choice, yet they'll still ...
  • northtexas: "There’ll be those out there that will love this song and defend it to death for the simple fact that ...

Recently Reviewed Albums

  • Charlie Louvin - Murder Ballads and Disaster Songs
  • Brandon Kinney - Smells Like Texas
  • Trace Adkins - X
  • Blake Shelton - Startin' Fires
  • Johnny Cash - At Folsom Prison Legacy Edition
  • Rodney Hayden - 12 Ounce World
  • Brad Paisley - Play
  • Randy Houser - Anything Goes