Album Review: The Wreckers – Way Back Home: Live from New York City

Matt C | December 6th, 2007 Email Share

wreckers.jpg Count me among those who are surprised and maybe a little bit disappointed that Michelle Branch and Jessica Harp’s country experiment didn’t work out. The duo’s surprisingly poor live performances are among the oft-cited factors in the their demise, and I witnessed more than one of their uncomfortable and malodroit television appearances. Way Back Home: Live from New York City thankfully lacks the disturbing, awkwardly hippy visual element that characterized those performances. What remains nevertheless reveals the deficiencies, and more significantly the inconsistencies, that consigned The Wreckers to one-hit-wonder status.

The Wreckers have publicly expressed their desire to make a bluegrass album and Stand Still, Look Pretty sounded trapped between those desires and a major label’s reluctance to embrace a traditional, rustic sound. What barely works on The Wreckers’ debut album falls flat in concert. The product sounds something like bad adult contemporary or lite rock with a tragically misinformed roots arrangement. This performance is all about clash. What was delightful harmony on Stand Still, Look Pretty is too often pitchy cacophony on Way Back Home. Electric guitars and far too much percussion replace acoustic instrumentation, mandolins are strummed like six-strings and fiddles amped-up beyond recognition. Songs like “Different Truck, Same Loser” and “Damn that Radio,” presumably from Branch’s upcoming solo project, and Branch album cuts like “Love Me Like That” are not weak per se but serve only to further bastardize the concert.

Not surprisingly, what works best on Stand Still, Look Pretty also works best in concert. “Crazy People” is a delightful narrative of a woman looking for love. “Stand Still, Look Pretty” is performed with a reserved acoustic accompaniment that makes it the album’s highlight. “Leave the Pieces” and “My, Oh My,” among the duo’s strongest material, sound rather heavy-handed in concert and are the only tracks that many listeners will recognize.

2 Stars

Leave a comment to be entered for a chance to win Way Back Home: Live from New York City. Three winners will be chosen at random and announced on Friday.

Watch: “Leave the Pieces:”

1 Trackbacks/Pings

Trackback URI for this post
  1. [...] a few free albums to the winners. As Napoleon Dynamite would say: Luckkyyyy. Also, if you’re interested in winning a free copy of The Wreckers’ latest live album, go read the review and leave a comment. We’ll be giving away three copies later this [...]

  1. Funk
    December 6, 2007 at 3:44 pm Permalink

    I was suspicious of The Wreckers from day one. I don’t know the second woman, but what kind of roots does Michelle Branch bring to country music? I figured it was just another contrived pairing to exploint a musical genre where women who can sing and look pretty often get instant attention.

    My feelings didn’t change one bit when I saw them opening for Keith Urban. I was blown away by Urban’s performance but my opinions about The Wreckers were formed before I was spoiled by his spectacular musical abilities and showmanship. It looked to me like The Wreckers are unbalanced. One of them seems to want the spotlight more than the other, and it’s not Branch. They never looked comfortable together and the perormance was boring. It didn’t look like they believed a word of what they were singing. It might be a simple problem like Branch has a ton more experience so she looks comfortable on stage while her partner works like crazy to keep up. Or, they might not have a country bone in their body.

    Either way, it was beyond boring. It was unpleasant.

  2. Jenny
    December 6, 2007 at 9:29 pm Permalink

    I think Michelle Branch should stay in the genre where she’s been successful and seems comfortable in: the pop/rock category. Jessica Harp, however, has always been more folk/country, and I think that the Wreckers is more Jessica’s style. I am happy to hear that both girls each making a solo album next. I am curious to see how Jessica Harp’s solo album will turn out.

  3. Kenny Christmas
    December 7, 2007 at 12:05 pm Permalink

    Jessica Harp actually looks like Jennifer Hanson.

  4. Janet Collier
    December 7, 2007 at 12:49 pm Permalink

    I would love to have this for Christmas!

  5. Angela
    December 7, 2007 at 12:51 pm Permalink

    Great Giveaway!!
    Im bloggin ya now
    http://contestaddict.blogspot.com

  6. emily
    December 7, 2007 at 1:09 pm Permalink

    I would love to win….desperate for some new tunes here….thanks!

  7. Josh Preister
    December 7, 2007 at 2:07 pm Permalink

    I was very skeptical of the Wrecker’s when they first came onto the country scene. I was thinking here comes another pop artist who can’t find a home on mainstream radio and is trying to make it on the country charts as so many are currently trying to do.

    But the Wreckers album hit me different. Beneath the emptiness that record executives forced onto some of the songs, there is something more here. These two ladies are writing and singing songs that I feel very much emphasize the story of country music. And I think that their more edgy songs that have maybe a tad more guitar and beat than country radio is used to, is the type of music that the younger audiences are favoring. And please don’t put me into the category of those young country music lovers who can’t live without their Rascal Flatts and “Save A Horse, Ride A Cowboy” generation, because that is not who I am. I am the country music listener is listening beyond the music for the lyrics. Give me a lyric like “Take the ribbon from your hair, shake it loose and let it fall, layin’ soft upon my skin. Like the shadows on the wall.” That’s a country music lyric if I have ever heard one. And if you don’t know who wrote that beautiful lyric, then for sure tune into some classic country and educate yourself.

    And I am not comparing the Wreckers to Kris, but if you listener closer than what I believe you are hearing, you will hear some good songs.

  8. Reg Matthews
    December 7, 2007 at 2:29 pm Permalink

    I don’t know these girls, but if they are country, count me in. This site is terrific!

  9. Lanibug65
    December 7, 2007 at 2:45 pm Permalink

    Hey, I like the Wreckers, I have their album on my ipod I like the music…I liked Michelle’s song on the Patsy Cline tribute album….she has a voice that can do country….another album of theirs would be great…

  10. Double-L
    December 7, 2007 at 3:15 pm Permalink

    Ya know, being from Arizona, when Michelle Branch walked into our Phoenix studios, people were busting at the seams to come hear her new project. Our Sedona girl going country? Must’ve been 3+ years ago now, but I was working at KNIX/Phoenix. Michelle and Jessica came in, sat down and sang. And it was magical. It really was. Gator Michaels told us it would be, so I was skeptical, but the way they sounded together just seemed RIGHT!

    Sweet, demure Jessica… perhaps a better “country” singer that Michelle that day. But the two of them, put together, singing different leads on different tunes… it was great.

    I was genuinely shocked to hear they were breaking up after only one album. I thought their sound was a fabulous addition to country radio! But, new babies and new boyfriends and creative differences… I guess all of that takes a toll.

    I saw the girls live three times and was lucky, I guess. They brought their “A” game each of those times and were very well-received.

    My favorite track from “Stand Still, Look Pretty” wasn’t even the countriest of the bunch. “RAIN” blew me away and I played it on repeat for at least three days straight.

    Hey, a great song is a great song. And for whatever reason, that one hit me where it counts.

    I bid a good luck to the girls… and before I leave, must say… Michelle has some KILLER tattoos! :)

  11. Wei
    December 7, 2007 at 5:12 pm Permalink

    I thought their debut album was great. I didn’t buy their new album, but would love a copy of it. I love “Cigarettes”; I think that song showcases Jessica Harp’s talent.

  12. Cindi Hoppes
    December 7, 2007 at 5:32 pm Permalink

    Please put me in your fabulous contest. Thanks,Cindi

  13. Brady Vercher
    December 7, 2007 at 6:27 pm Permalink

    Congrats to Angela, Double-L, and Wei for winning the copies of The Wreckers’ album.

    Funk, my thoughts were the same when The Wreckers came out about Michelle Branch crossing over so I never paid them much attention, opting instead to see if they’d stick around.

  14. Lucas
    December 14, 2007 at 11:12 am Permalink

    Here’s my problem with The Wreckers…
    First let me start by saying that I’m one of those guys that think somebody from New York City can be a million times more country than somebody from No-Name-Town, Texas as long as their music and songs are right.

    But The Wreckers to me, just aren’t country. By no means am I saying they’re not talented, they’re obviously talented. They’re just not country.

    Picking up a guitar and singing a cheating song doesn’t make you country. I think the problem with The Wreckers is everybody knew beforehand that Michelle Branch was a pop singer, and that’s a big no-no among country fans. Country is just going through another contemporary phase, it will bounce back.

    If you’re a pop singer and that’s what you love, stay a pop singer. Very few are going to be able to successfully cross over and maintain any kind of longevity.

Leave a Comment


Sponsor

New American Voices Video

Tagged In This Article

//

Current Discussion

  • Terry Ridont: I think its cool. Thats what I like about indy rock artists, everything isn't the same high budget packaging and ...
  • Stormy: Jon: The problem is that the progressive country music is now being called Americana. And why is it ...
  • Razor X: Maybe his brother did talk him into it but what’s to say he hasn’t ‘always loved’ and ‘wanted’ to ...
  • Brian: Josh Kelley will be fine. At the very least it means Katherine Heigl may show up on country award shows regularly. ...
  • Razor X: Change may be inevitable but we aren't required to support it and if enough people boycott it, it doesn't last ...
  • Jon: "You can’t stop “progress”… We can if we try hard enough. Um, no. Not that I think "progress" is a good ...
  • Joe: When she moved from Mercury to BNA, I think we were all just allowed to think there'd be some grand ...
  • sam sam: Well, Suzie, maybe if I saw his live show I'd love him. But I'm not interested in attending concerts. Radio ...
  • JOHN: Personally Sherrie s voice is as pure as it gets to me. Just listened to her demo songs after reading ...
  • Suzie: What is all this hate for Bucky about anyway?? He has one of the best voices in country music ...

Recently Reviewed Albums

  • clark-icon
  • cheticon
  • natural-forces-icon
  • carrie-icon
  • Sam Bush - Circles Around Me
  • Dolly Parton - Dolly
  • Drew Kennedy - An Audio Guide to Cross Country Travel
  • Toby Keith - American Ride