Album Review: Becky Schlegel – For All The World To See

Jim Malec | June 9th, 2008 Email Share

Becky Schlegel - For All The World To SeeWith her debut national release, South Dakota native Becky Schlegel showcases a soft warble of a voice that meets the ears like a gentle, moist kiss on the cheek. Never forceful, and at times little more than a whisper, For All The World To See is a fusion of folk, roots, and bluegrass that quietly positions itself as one of the most unexpected country albums of 2008.

Schlegel, a veteran of NPR’s A Prairie Home Companion, sings in an airy, almost girlish soprano that often channels Alison Krauss but still brims with its own unique character, all at once sensual and vulnerable.

From the remarkable “Jenny,” a heartbreaking newgrass narrative that reminds of Nickel Creek, to the serene “Sound Of Your Voice,” For All The World To See brings together Schlegel’s inventive melodies with production that smartly avoids trying too hard to establish itself as wholly bluegrass, a fact that allows the project to focus on what really matters–that voice.

While Schlegel is an average lyricist and a decent technical singer, it is the sincerity and character of her delivery, combined with the intriguing color of her voice, that ultimately marks For All The World To See as an album that deserves the attention of fans of progressive bluegrass.

The album’s title track is a shining example of the way in which Schlegel’s skill as a stylist overshadows her skill as a writer; “For All The World To See” is a mediocre song that is nevertheless a joy to listen to because of the impeccable way Schlegel draws out every ounce of emotion from it. And so is true of lead single “Bound For Tennessee,” a typical “leaving my small-town home” song that goes absolutely nowhere lyrically, but which Schlegel manages to render unique and engaging anyway.

When all is said and done, For All The World To See is significantly burdened by its lack of standout material. Despite the fact that Schlegel’s writing is vivid and poignant, it sometimes lacks a sense of sharpness or urgency–two attributes which would play well in contrast to her calm and understated vocal approach. Still, one of the marks of a truly compelling singer is that she can make average songs sound great–something which Schlegel does throughout.

3 Stars

Recommended Tracks: “Jenny“, “Sound Of Your Voice“, “Spotlight“.

Becky Schlegel on MySpace

  1. dudley
    June 9, 2008 at 9:13 am Permalink

    I’m so glad you reviewed this one, Jim. I heard “Bound for Tennessee” online a couple of weeks ago and immediately ran to Schlegel’s MySpace page because I really thought Schlegel elevated the single with a lovely interpretive performance. The tone of her voice is a neat mix of Lee Ann Womack’s fragility and Alison Krauss’ haunting beauty. I agree with you that her lyrics can be a bit pedestrian, but somehow the melody, production and her vocals come together really well and make the songs more than they are. “Jenny” is a definite standout.

  2. Rick
    June 9, 2008 at 10:32 am Permalink

    If ever there was an artist that needed a made up stage last name, Becky is it! Schlegel sounds like something from yiddish slang…. (Geez, I’m kiding).

    Becky’s music is interesting and will appeal to PHC fans, but I need something that is more likely to keep me awake while driving. Garrison Keilor just loves mellow folk artists like The Wailin’ Jenny’s, so its not surprising Becky is a cast member.

    If instead someone wants bluegrass/newgrass related female vocals that knock your socks off, then the “Listen To The Music” album by 3 Fox Drive can’t be beat! There are a lot of great female vocalists working in the bluegrass related realm, but the Fox Sisters are my favorites. If 3 Fox Drive were to perform on Prairie Home Companion, their high energy level might cause anxiety attacks in the laid back audience! (lol)

Leave a Comment


Sponsor

New American Voices Video

Tagged In This Article

Current Discussion

  • Please!: 'I find Carrie’s music to be a fresh of breath air and anybody who doesn’t feel this can easily find ...
  • Rick: Speaking of polite company, King Rat Obama and his fellow democrat vermin in the U.S. House of Representatives (and one ...
  • Steve M.: I don't mind songs with political overtones-after all, Woody Guthrie wrote most of his tunes with a solid political bent, ...
  • Vance: Only a superfan of Carrie would think I'm bitter as her fanbase is unable to take hearing any criticism about ...
  • Dan E.: Vance: You seem a little bitter.
  • Dan E.: Kurt: I bet you'd be surprised at how many people are both fans of Carrie and Taylor. Only a small ...
  • Vance: The lyrics are actually, “boy meets girl, girl leaves boy” Also, I’m loving her fresh music. It's not fresh music, it's cookie ...
  • kurt: I personally don’t think there’s anything inherently wrong with a country artist working with someone like Martin or Dioguardi if ...
  • kurt: Thank you! Thank you! Carrie fans seem to think that “remixing” is the only way to make a country song ...
  • Leeann Ward: Michael, That's ridiculous on more than one level.

Recently Reviewed Albums

  • carrie-icon
  • Sam Bush - Circles Around Me
  • Dolly Parton - Dolly
  • Drew Kennedy - An Audio Guide to Cross Country Travel
  • Toby Keith - American Ride
  • svicon
  • closer-to-the-bone
  • revolution